It looks like you're visiting from
Select your preferred country or region to see content, offerings, and pricing  specific to your location.
Vous consultez actuellement notre site depuis le
Sélectionnez votre pays ou région pour accéder aux contenus, offres et tariffs adaptés à votre localization.
arrow_back
Back
Property market economics

A conflict of interest

Last updated on:
Published on:
November 17, 2026
By:
Cotality
Woman and a man looking at a tablet.

Non-QM loans are part of the equation helping investors expand their footprint in the property market.

  • Financing edge: Five-year, interest-only loans can maximize rental margins over short hold periods.
  • Market shift: As institutional investment retreats, mom-and-pop buyers stepped in, acquiring 20% more homes than they sold.
  • Buyer fallout: Heavy investor demand keeps prices and rents high, contributing to locking gig and freelance workers out of ownership.
  • Millions of Americans now embrace freelancing, small-business ownership, or gig-economy careers, but the industry hasn’t widely adopted lending structures that correspond to this shift. Add to that dynamic the increasingly unaffordable price tag for homes, and many would-be homeowners are stuck as renters.  

    Many are renting from similarly minded entrepreneurs: mom-and-pop investors.  

    The difference is that investors are turning to non-QM mortgages to finance property transactions, according to Cotatlity data. Many are doing so to take advantage of interest-only payments.

    The five-year flip

    The U.S. housing market offers an ideal proposition to small investors. Rents have increased 25% in the last five years, the federal government has curbed institutional investment, and home equity continues to rise.

    Investors are responding by reasserting their presence in markets across the U.S. Cotality data shows that the share of investors making home purchases has climbed since mid-2022 and now represents about a third of all transactions. Small investors represent about half of that transaction volume.  

    Investment transactions occur frequently, making them an ideal candidate for interest-only loans. Nearly half of investor hold onto a property for five years or less — that precise timeframe makes an interest-only mortgage worth the equity tradeoff. Most interest-only loans have an initial period of five years before principal repayment begins where monthly commitments are reduced to create wider profit margins on rents.

    While investors who finance this way won’t reap the benefits of accrued equity, they can profit from the persistently high home prices and a tight inventory that makes short-term commitments profitable.

    How long does each investor type hold property

    Data source: Cotality, 2026

    The U.S. is short 4.7 million homes. The ones that are available are in high demand. Add in mortgage rates near 7%, and affordability is being tested at its limits. Home prices reflect that squeeze.  

    That dynamic has allowed investors in states like California, where they buy over a third of all homes, to profit on investments financed by interest-only loans. Investors nearly doubled the number of purchases they made in Los Angeles between Q1 and Q2 2026. Home prices jumped 2% during that period.

    This localized surge in investment is colliding directly with broader national price pressures—a dynamic we analyzed in our piece, Bend It Like Buyers. In major metros, that friction has created a stalemate between buyers and sellers, leaving the door open to more financially flexible investors. Many blame Wall Street.

    Institutional investors ban themselves

    Injecting corporate-backed demand into a market where local buyers are already stretched, extends even the most flexible buyers past their breaking point. Local residents who are priced out of home purchases find themselves competing with incoming industrial contractors for the exact same rental inventory.

    The resulting rent escalation drives up investor yields in the short term, but it simultaneously compresses local household purchasing power and accelerates affordability risk.

    That has a direct influence on local markets. In states like California, Texas, and Georgia, where investors buy over a third of all homes, prices have risen disproportionately. In Texas, home prices jumped 38% as investor share climbed to 31% between 2020 and 2023. In Georgia, prices jumped 54% alongside an investor share increase to 29%.  

    But the passage of the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Bill disrupted that playbook.  

    Even before the passage of the bill, Cotality data shows that institutional investment contracted from around 250 home purchases a week to 100. Mom-and-pop investors filled the gap.  

    Small-time landlords entered a market where equity was on the rise, which allowed them to build a cash cushion to insulate them from current high-interest rates and create wider profit margins that allow them to redeploy capital elsewhere. When that equity cushion is layered atop monthly rental income profit, these landlords can offset systemic hurdles such as interest rates and rising home insurance costs.

    Much of that extra capital is going into increasing their market share. Small mom-and-pop investors purchased 20% more homes than they offloaded last year, according to Cotality data. Their persistent presence is reshaping the housing market.  

    Main street moves in

    Across the country, investors are the ones with the financial wherewithal to purchase homes in the current high-cost, high-rate environment. This is contributing to keeping costs — from home prices to rents — elevated and widening the gap for aspiring homeowners.  

    Some renters will be blocked from homeowership by these costs. Others will bend and stretch to make the homeownership math work. Some will look to non-QM mortgages themselves.  

    Forward-looking lenders who are optimizing for long-term growth will cater to both sides. There is now a path forward. It may be unconventional, but it is a door through which an increasing number of investors and homeowners are stepping to make the dream of homeownership a reality.  

    Related Insights (0)

    No items found.
    Property market economics
    Mortgage banking & financial technology
    No items found.