It looks like you're visiting from
Select your preferred country or region to see content, offerings, and pricing  specific to your location.
arrow_back
Back
Property market economics

The cost of 30 years of certainty

Last updated on:
Published on:
November 11, 2026
By:
Archana Pradhan
A young couple signing paperwork

As mortgage rates top 7%, buyers increasingly turn to adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs) for monthly savings despite future reset risks.

  • Upfront savings: A 5/1 ARM lowers initial rates by ~1%, saving ~$3,900 annually on a $500,000 loan.
  • Volume surge: ARMs now account for 20% of mortgage dollar volume, led by high-cost states.
  • Strong credit profile: Serious delinquency on post-2010 ARMs sits below 0.5%, proving more resilient than fixed-rate loans

There is now a nearly $4,000 annual difference between paying for a $500,000 home with a fixed-rate mortgage and an adjustable-rate mortgage. That figure only grows alongside price. As affordability pushes buyers to make sacrifices, Cotality data shows that there’s been an increase in the number of buyers taking advantage of those extra funds afforded by adjustable-rate mortgages.  

The savings secured with these flexible mortgages is meaningful, but it’s not stable.  

“Buyers are taking a bet as affordability wears them down,” said Cotality Principal Economist Archana Pradhan, “They’re choosing available cash in the short term over a guarantee of consistent payments down the road. That solution has very market-dependent results.”

An ARM to lean on

Conventional wisdom has historically pushed buyers toward adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs) when rates are rising. The thinking goes: lock in a rate for 5, 7, or 10 years and then refinance before the mortgage’s fixed period ends. That logic still holds appeal. With current mortgage rates above 7%, people taking out a conventional mortgage today will have a higher rate than most current homeowners; Cotality data shows only 28% of mortgages have interest rates above 5%. Taking out a 5-year ARM at current rates would drop a borrower’s interest rate down around a full point. Accordingly, a full 20% of mortgage dollar volumes are allocated to ARMs, according to Cotality data.  

However, if the rate adjusts upward following a fixed period, it can quickly eat away at earlier savings. And that reality is a distinct possibility. Cotality economists anticipate that current rates reflect a new normal rather than an anomaly.

“Since the 2010s, rates have hovered around 2 to 5 basis points below where they are today. And then pandemic-era rates reset expectations to unrealistic levels,” said Pradhan. “People taking out ARMs today shouldn’t expect the rock-bottom-rates of 2020-2022 when they refinance down the road.”

A refinance at the wrong time risks leaving someone exposed to larger monthly payments — and possible default.  

Buyers are taking a bet as affordability wears them down. They’re choosing available cash in the short term over a guarantee of consistent payments down the road. That solution has very market-dependent results.
Archana Pradhan
Cotality Principal Economist

The price of popularity

Affordability is pushing many buyers to the edge. Cotality tracks how homebuyers feel about price pressures, and in a recent survey, 69% of buyers said they were willing to cut lifestyle spending to afford a home. Sixty-five percent seek smaller mortgages for lower monthly payments. 

Buyers’ eagerness to take on ARMs underscores how strained they are; a few hundred dollars can make the difference between ending the month in the black or the red. Should an adjustable rate mortgage term come up for renewal, current rates could tip monthly payments past the point where homeowners’ finances can absorb the increase.

However, Cotality data shows that ARMs are not any more prone to mortgage delinquencies than conventional mortgages. Adjustable-rate mortgages originated after 2010 have a strong track record. Only 0.5% of ARMs from this category are seriously delinquent (90 days or more late), which is slightly lower than fixed rate loans. Even during the economic disruption of early 2020, adjustable mortgages saw serious delinquencies top out at 3.0% as compared to around 3.5% for fixed-rate loans.

That’s because households rarely let the mortgage go at the first sign of trouble. Instead, they find room elsewhere in the budget, a trend recorded in Cotality survey data.  

The strain on homeowner finances is chronic, and buyers are already making lifestyle sacrifices to make the math work. Sixty-five percent of homebuyers will take out a smaller mortgage to lower monthly payments. For the Gen Z buyers, that figure is 82%.  

But a smaller mortgage isn’t always possible. In high-cost areas like Washington State, California, and New York, average home prices are $255,000, $324,000, $269,000 above the national average, according to Cotality data. Transactions haven’t slowed, buyers have just become increasingly dependent on ARM loans.

Conventional ARM share (by loan $ amount)

The math here is straightforward: the bigger the mortgage, the more actual cash an introductory rate discount saves every month. In expensive markets, even a modest percentage-point drop in rates adds up to serious money.  

‍

Measuring the cost of a mortgage

Metric 30-Year Fixed (7.50%) 5/1 ARM (6.54%) Your Monthly Discount
P&I Payment ($500,000 Loan) ~$3,500 / month ~$3,175 / month ~$325 / month
Annualized Outlay ~$42,000 / year ~$38,100 / year ~$3,900 / year

An exit plan

Breathing room in a budget is a new form of stability. More homeowners are looking to make that room by reducing monthly payments, and adjustable-rate mortgages provide a way to do so without tightening the belt elsewhere.

Others are trimming their lifestyles to make homeownership possible. But there are a finite number of sacrifices that buyers can make. As margins become thinner, and as people look for ways to enter the market even at higher rates, alternative mortgage types provide a pathway forward.

Related Insights (0)

No items found.
Property market economics
Housing affordability
Mortgage banking & financial technology
No items found.