73%
U.S. homebuyers who would pay extra to feel at home in their neighborhood
92%
Respondents who consider a personal perception of safety to count when choosing a neighborhood
61%
U.S. homebuyers who would accept a less ideal home for an ideal neighborhood
Introduction
In Cotality’s Q3 2026 global survey of recent and prospective homebuyers, 56% said they would accept a less ideal home to live in the right place. With a majority of buyers showing a willingness to reconsider the home under the right circumstances, housing professionals have more of a reason than ever to ask what “belonging” means to the buyer in front of them.
Willingness to pay extra and compromise by generation
Millennials seem most willing to revisit their home shopping list to optimize for location. Three in four (74%) say they would pay extra for belonging, and 66% would accept a less ideal home. Among Baby Boomers, the figures are 58% and 43%.
Data source: Cotality Q3 Consumer Sentiment Survey, 2026
For an agent, a preferred area is a reason to reopen the original property brief. Ask what makes the neighborhood worth the compromise on home specs and which requirements of a dream home the buyer would reconsider. Record what remains unresolved after the viewing. That gives the next conversation a purpose, whether it calls for another visit, a review of the available property data, or a clearer account of the buyer’s priorities. Incorporating such considerations into AI platforms used across the buyer journey will also be essential as adoption increases.
The degree to which people prioritize neighborhoods above homes is part of the budget conversations. A lender can help a borrower examine the home now under consideration and any costs they have identified. An insurer can encourage the buyer to seek a property-specific quote while they still have a choice. Why? Because agreement to a less ideal home does not always mean the buyer has investigated its condition or the cost of insuring it.
The agent belongs in the conversation
Many buyers consider neighborhood guidance to be part of an agent’s role, with 51% considering it appropriate for an agent to share verified neighborhood reports. Personal observations and help finding resources for lifestyle or community questions each attract 49%.
What do homebuyers say they need from real estate agents
Data source: Cotality Q3 Consumer Sentiment Survey, 2026
Only 11% said they want to limit an agent’s guidance on property specifications and legal sales transactions, avoiding neighborhood discussions entirely. The question asks what buyers consider appropriate; it does not establish that every buyer expects each service.
“When a buyer says an area feels right, ask what they mean. Their answer can help you drill down to what they truly need in a location or property and provide the data to support or reject a property before they make an offer,” explained Kevin Greene, Cotality’s GM of Real Estate Solutions.
The local meaning of belonging
“They were welcoming and friendly and kind of stayed out of the way of other people when needed." A U.S. Gen Z buyer offered that description of their neighbors. At first glance that reads like a recipe that leaves room for a welcome and a life of one’s own. But what feels right to the person buying the home can be difficult to capture in a property listing.
An agent needs to hear what the buyer has in mind before helping them decide whether an area is worth paying extra for or accepting a home they might otherwise have passed over.
What someone looks for to feel like they belong varies across the five markets surveyed. U.S. respondents express the greatest willingness to pay extra for belonging. Australians are most willing to reconsider the property itself. In the UK, buyers’ concerns about what they might discover after moving offer a particular opening for better local information. These findings suggest where housing professionals could begin their questions.
What counts when buyers choose an area
Once a picture of an ideal neighborhood is painted, it also has to feel right. People want to belong, but “belonging” has a different definition for everyone. Sixty-nine percent say they would pay extra for a strong sense of belonging. Just 14% choose the deepest level of neighborhood involvement, and 87% consider privacy important. Some 81% chose a point in between.
What makes a neighborhood home
Data source: Cotality Q3 Consumer Sentiment Survey, 2026
Of course, the reasons behind the rankings are often very individual, but the survey identified some clear common ground. From this group in the large middle ground, 67% would pay extra for that feeling of belonging, 56% would accept a less ideal home, and 85% consider privacy important.
The social setting buyers want
Data source: Cotality Q3 Consumer Sentiment Survey, 2026; Respondents chose one point on a five-point scale. Only the endpoints carried descriptions; the three positions between them were unlabeled. Percentages rounded.
Searching – and paying – to feel at home
Feeling at home requires being surrounded a variety of viewpoints. Shared outlook ranks among the strongest influences on the choice for relatively few buyers.
Across the survey, 10% put similar social, cultural, or lifestyle mindsets in their top three neighborhood factors; 7% select political or religious characteristics. Privacy makes the top three for 24%. Recognizing these different perspectives on what constitutes a buyer’s sense of belonging means there is typically still much left for an agent to learn.
Those who do learn how people want to belong stand to influence the final choice of buyers. Seventy percent would pay extra for belonging, and 58% would accept a less ideal home to make that happen.
A global snapshot of neighborhood preference
Data source: Cotality Q3 Consumer Sentiment Survey, 2026; All figures combine recent and prospective buyers within each country. Agreement combines somewhat and strongly agree; importance combines somewhat and very important. Results are unweighted and rounded. The measures are separate responses and do not establish how many buyers hold several views.
United States: Belonging earns a place in the budget
For U.S. buyers, the feeling of being at home in an area deserves attention early in the search. Some 73% would pay extra for belonging, the highest share among the five markets, and 61% would accept a less ideal home. Agents have a reason to ask what makes an area worth those concessions. Lenders can help buyers examine what the preferred property would mean for their budget beyond the initial price tag.
Australia: The property brief is open for discussion
An Australian buyer who finds the right neighborhood may have reason to take another look at the homes they initially ruled out. Some 67% would accept a less ideal property, the highest share across the five markets. For an agent, that means revisiting which requirements remain essential to selecting a house. If greater maintenance enters the discussion, lenders and insurers can establish rapport by helping buyers identify the costs that come after deciding on the right home.
United Kingdom: A good impression leaves questions
A visit carries considerable weight for UK respondents: 79% put their impressions ahead of official neighborhood statistics. Some 73% also worry about discovering negative issues after moving in — like what happens on the street when they’re not there to see. There is an opening here for agents and platforms to help buyers investigate the questions that linger after a viewing. Verified noise and activity reports would be useful to 59%, and nuisance complaint information to 56%, the highest shares across the five markets for those information types.
Canada: Leave room for a little distance
Privacy is important to 91% of Canadian respondents. Some 65% would pay extra for belonging, while 8% choose the deepest level of community involvement. An agent needs to give those preferences room to be explained. What would make the buyer feel welcome, and how much involvement would suit them? Those answers could help refine the search and give neighborhood information a clearer purpose. The figures describe separate preferences; they leave each buyer’s preferred arrangement to be discovered.
New Zealand: Explore what buyers would reconsider
In New Zealand, just 4% seek neighborhoods with the deepest community involvement, giving professionals another reason to ask what belonging would look like in the buyer’s daily life. Individual answers matter since only 54% would pay extra for belonging, the lowest share among the five markets. Some 52% would accept a less ideal home for the right neighborhood. Agents can use those questions to explore how a buyer weighs the area against the property, without assuming either concession is a given. Lenders can then work through the full budget for the home under consideration.
Deciding under pressure
Getting to know a neighborhood takes time. A buyer may want to walk the street after dark or visit on a weekend before deciding it feels like home. Across the five countries surveyed, 44% of recent and prospective buyers say the current market requires faster decisions when finding a property. For an agent, that is a reason to ask up front what the buyer needs to know about a neighborhood before even visiting a home. Cotality’s Homebuyer Pressure Index scores 40 out of 100, tracking overwhelm and urgency across finding a home, choosing a mortgage and arranging insurance.
What the same budget buys
One recent buyer in New Zealand described what they wanted to know: “What the surrounding homes were like. Values of these homes. Visiting the area at differing times to get a feel for it. Ease of access for regular services.”
For a lender, that inquiry is a useful reminder of how a purchase decision takes shape. The borrower may be weighing several homes and a changing set of priorities. If the preferred location leads them to consider a different property, the discussion should follow that property: the proposed borrowing, the costs already identified, and any work still to assess.
“If the buyer reconsiders a home because they want to stay in a specific area, rerun the budget with them. Ask which costs are fixed and which are flexible. Any willingness to compromise tells us little about what they can afford," explained Greene.
The viewing after the viewing
A future buyer in Canada had something more particular in mind as they assess their options: “I would want to know how busy the road is, whether it's near a fire station (which can make it loud), what the neighbors are like.” The concern is easy to miss during a short visit, but also specific enough to investigate.
Across the full sample of respondents, 73% believe they can quickly tell whether an area feels right by visiting. Among that group, 65% also worry about discovering negative neighborhood issues after moving in. Verified, current reports on noise and activity at different times would be useful to 51% of respondents. Resident ratings of how welcoming and friendly the neighborhood is attract 47%; nuisance and antisocial behavior information attracts 46%.
What neighborhood data do buyers care about?
Data source: Cotality Q3 Consumer Sentiment Survey, 2026
A walk around the neighborhood can tell a buyer things they would struggle to put into a search box. Across the survey, 73% give more weight to what they see, hear or learn during a visit than to official neighborhood statistics. Among that group, 51% would still welcome verified reports on noise and activity. They may like the street and want to know what it sounds like when they are trying to sleep.
But getting those answers can take some work. One in five say they struggle to find reliable information about how long residents stay or how often they move; 18% have difficulty judging noise at different times. The Canadian buyer wondering about a nearby fire station had a question worth taking on a second visit. And that buyer isn’t the only one with these questions.
How do buyers get a sense of neighborhood safety
Data source: Cotality Q3 Consumer Sentiment Survey, 2026
Future buyers plan more checks than recent buyers report having made. These are separate groups, describing intentions and past behavior. Among prospective buyers, 23% are very confident their methods will reveal the issues they fear misjudging, and another 45% are somewhat confident. That leaves an agent with a potentially useful question: which concern would the buyer most like to settle before making an offer? Property platforms can help by making the source, date, and coverage of the information clear.
A local price figure will not tell a buyer whether a street is noisy or a neighbor welcoming. The evidence offered needs to address the question they are asking.
Living with the decision
Moving in often brought welcome discoveries. Some 38% of recent buyers reported mainly positive surprises, and another 25% found a mixture of good and bad. Mainly negative surprises accounted for 6%. Across recent buyers, 83% would probably or definitely choose the same home again. It’s those with buyers’ remorse who signal a pattern that deserves attention.
“The level of noise was a surprise”. That was one U.S. Gen X buyer’s account. Another U.S. buyer, a Millennial, wrote: “If it was safe enough to walk around in at night. It's not, but you find out the hard way”. Both were answering the open question about what they wanted to know before buying. Their answers describe what they learned afterwards. Among recent buyers reporting positive and negative surprises, 71% would probably or definitely buy the same home again. Among those whose neighborhood was as expected, the figure is 93%.
Neighborhood expectations vs reality
Data source: Cotality Q3 Consumer Sentiment Survey, 2026. Within each category, the answers do not distinguish pleasant discoveries from unwelcome ones. The differences in willingness to buy again cannot establish what caused buyers to reconsider.
Among recent buyers reporting positive, negative, or mixed surprises, 48% mention neighborhood behavior or attitudes, 48% safety or crime, and 37% noise or activity.
Helping buyers test a feeling
A buyer who has found the right neighborhood may be willing to live with a house that needs more attention. In the survey, 59% would accept a less ideal home if the area felt right, with home size and greater maintenance offered as examples. For an insurance underwriter, “more maintenance” leaves several questions unanswered. What needs doing and how much does that cost? What has already been repaired? What is the buyer planning to leave until later?
The answers need to come from the property. The age and condition of the roof; electrical wiring and plumbing; the maintenance history and exposure to natural hazards all help insurers assess a home’s risk. A buyer’s willingness to take on work tells the underwriter little about those details.
This gives insurers a reason to enter the conversation while the buyer is still weighing the purchase. Asking early for property details, repair records, or an inspection where needed could help establish the terms on which cover might be available. It also gives the buyer time to ask what those terms would mean for them.
Of course, the survey cannot tell us whether buyers who compromise on a home become greater insurance risks. It does suggest a useful question to put alongside their enthusiasm for the neighborhood: how much do they know about the house they are prepared to accept?
“Buyers need to consider how their compromises on a ‘less ideal’ home translate into insurance availability and coverage costs," said Cotality's Chief Scientist Howard Botts. "An estimate or coverage prequalification before closing gives them something specific to examine: the proposed terms, the cost and any questions to resolve. Those details can redefine deals.”
Five questions about the intangibles of homebuying
How much community involvement do homebuyers want?
Buyers placed themselves on a five-point scale from total anonymity and minimal interaction to deep relationships and frequent community involvement. 81% chose a point between those endpoints; 5% chose the anonymity endpoint and 14% the deep-relationships endpoint. The three intervening positions were unlabeled, so they cannot tell us exactly what contact buyers want.
Would homebuyers pay extra for a sense of belonging?
Across the survey, 69% say they would pay extra for a home in a community where they feel a strong sense of belonging. Among buyers choosing a point between the two endpoints, 67% agree. The survey specifies no premium amount and does not measure premiums actually paid.
Would buyers accept a less ideal home for the right neighborhood?
Yes. In the combined sample, 59% say they would accept a less ideal property if the neighborhood felt right. Among buyers choosing a point between the two endpoints, the figure is 56%. The question gave home size and greater maintenance as examples. Respondents did not choose individual concessions or report which they had made.
What neighborhood information do buyers want before purchasing?
Verified, current reports on noise and activity at different times would be useful to 51% of the combined sample. Resident ratings of welcome and friendliness attract 47%; information on nuisance and antisocial behavior complaints attracts 46%. Respondents could select several types of information.
How does neighborhood experience relate to buying the same home again?
Among recent buyers reporting both positive and negative neighborhood surprises, 71% would probably or definitely buy the same home again, compared with 93% of those whose neighborhood was as expected. The association does not establish that the neighborhood experience caused purchase reconsideration.



