It looks like you're visiting from
Select your preferred country or region to see content, offerings, and pricing  specific to your location.
Vous consultez actuellement notre site depuis le
Sélectionnez votre pays ou région pour accéder aux contenus, offres et tariffs adaptés à votre localization.
arrow_back
Back
Podcast episode

NZ Housing Market Q3: Property Resale Losses Reach Highest Share Since 2012

timelapse
37 mins
 min listen
calendar_month
November 16, 2026

Featuring

Host
Nick Goodall
Head of Research
Cotality New Zealand
Speakers
Kelvin Davidson
Sr Professional, Research
Cotality NZ

Send us a question/idea/opinion direct via text message!

In this episode of the New Zealand Property Market Podcast, Nick Goodall and Kelvin Davidson unpack the latest Cotality Q3 Pain and Gain Report. With property values having drifted lower since the peak, 16% of resales in the third quarter went for less than the original purchase price - the highest share of gross losses since 2012. Even so, more than four in five sellers still walked away with a gross profit (a median gain of $270,000), showing just how much hold period matters (10.5 years for gains versus 4.5 years for losses).

We also examine why 48% of apartment resales recorded a loss, why 26% of listings nationwide failed to sell within three months, and how a patchy economy - rising manufacturing activity (16 straight months above 50) and 22,600 annual net migration versus falling retail card spending - is keeping both the sales and rental markets in check. Plus, we discuss Westpac's move to factor flood and hazard risk into mortgage lending criteria and preview our upcoming Territorial Authority flood vulnerability analysis.

  • Key Topics Covered:
    • Q3 Pain and Gain findings (16% pain vs 84% gain, $270k median profit), apartments (48% loss share) vs townhouses (22%) vs standalone houses (13%), and why Te Whanganui-a-Tara (Wellington) has fewer withdrawn listings than Tāmaki Makaurau (Auckland).
    • Patchy economic indicators (Stats NZ vs ANZ/Westpac card spending, PMI at 16 months of expansion, net migration at 22,600) and why high living costs are suppressing household formation and rental demand.
    • Westpac's climate and flood risk lending adjustments (affecting ~2-3% of applications), the upcoming national flood map, the Strand Marsden research project with the University of Otago, and Cotality's property-level flood scores.
    • Wales ending a 73-year drought against the All Blacks in Cardiff, the Kiwis vs Kangaroos final, Flight of the Conchords live, All Whites & Wellington Phoenix Women wins, and Black Caps Test cricket at the Basin Reserve.
  • Download the Q3 Pain & Gain Report: https://www.cotality.com/nz/insights/articles/property-resale-losses-hit-highest-level-since-2012
  • Read our upcoming Flood Risk Analysis: https://www.cotality.com/nz/insights

Sign up for news and insights or contact on LinkedIn, X @NickGoodall_CL or @KDavidson_CL and email ngoodall@cotality.com or kdavidson@cotality.com

This podcast is for educational and entertainment purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, or tax advice. The hosts are not licensed Financial Advice Providers in New Zealand. All information is of a general nature and does not take into account your personal situation or goals. Please consult a qualified professional before making any financial decisions.

Nick Goodall (00:01):
And welcome to the New Zealand Property Market Podcast, brought to you by Cotality for the sixteenth of November 2026. I am Head of Research, Nick Goodall, and today I am joined, as per usual, by Chief Economist, Kelvin Davidson. Kelvin, it was a not-so-super Sunday of sports results yesterday, which we will cover off later in the show. First, we released the Cotality third-quarter Pain and Gain Report last week. Can you take us through the key findings and how the media coverage went?

Kelvin Davidson (00:26):
We received really strong media coverage. I suspect journalists were looking for a fresh topic outside of the New Zealand general election, so the third-quarter Cotality Pain and Gain Report arrived at just the right time.

The headline takeaway is that resellers are experiencing a bit more "pain" and a bit less "gain". That continues a trend we have tracked for some time, which is completely consistent with falling property values. In a buyer's market, more sellers end up transacting for less than they originally paid. In the third quarter of 2026, sixteen percent of property resales achieved a gross sale price below their original purchase price. That sixteen percent loss-making share is the highest we have recorded since 2012, highlighting just how weak market conditions are for sellers.

Of course, there are two ways to look at the figures. While sixteen percent is a painful number for those sellers, it still means more than four in every five resellers—eighty-four percent—walked away with a gross profit. However, the size of those resale profits has also declined. The median resale gain across New Zealand fell to two hundred and seventy thousand dollars in the third quarter, down substantially from the peak of around four hundred and forty thousand dollars a few years ago. Even so, a gross profit of two hundred and seventy thousand dollars remains significant for those long-term owners.

Another notable feature of this housing cycle is that the rise in loss-making resales has been a slow burner. After the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), the proportion of loss-making resales jumped from near zero in 2007 to between eighteen and twenty percent within just two years. In the current cycle, moving from near zero to sixteen percent has taken four to five years. That slower trajectory reflects the fact that employment has held up relatively well until recently, preventing a wave of forced sales or mortgagee defaults.

As always, the hold period remains critical. In the third quarter, resales that achieved a gross profit had a median hold period of ten and a half years, whereas resales that recorded a gross loss had a median hold period of roughly four and a half years. Anyone who bought four or five years ago purchased right near the 2021–2022 market peak, making it very difficult to resell in a short timeframe without taking a loss.

By property type, apartments fared the worst in the third quarter, with forty-eight percent—nearly half—of apartment resales recording a gross loss, compared to twenty-two percent for townhouses and thirteen percent for standalone houses. Apartments typically experience lower capital growth over time, meaning owners have less equity buffer during a downturn. It is also worth noting that apartments represent a relatively small share of total New Zealand property transactions. The actual number of loss-making apartment sales did not change dramatically in the third quarter; rather, because standalone house transactions drifted lower, apartment losses made up a larger percentage share.

Overall, the third-quarter Pain and Gain Report is a sign of the times rather than evidence of a fresh market collapse. Because property values are unlikely to rebound sharply anytime soon, sellers who need or want to transact over the coming quarters will continue selling into a soft market, keeping the proportion of loss-making resales elevated for a while yet.

Nick Goodall (06:11):
Exactly. Because the report received such widespread media coverage, both of us completed several interviews last week, and a few important caveats kept coming up. First, the Cotality Pain and Gain Report measures the gross difference between the original purchase price and the resale price—it does not account for buying and selling costs, interest paid, or renovation expenses, nor does it adjust for Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation.

During the media rounds, a spokesperson for the New Zealand Property Investors' Federation rightly pointed out that once you factor in inflation, the real financial hit for sellers crystallising a loss—or making only a small nominal gain—is even steeper. However, keeping the Pain and Gain methodology simple allows us to track consistent relativity over time all the way back to the Global Financial Crisis, as well as comparing performance across different regions and property types.

When we split the third-quarter data between owner-occupiers and property investors, there was very little difference in the share of loss-making sales between the two groups. We are not seeing a mass exodus of investors dumping properties at heavy losses, nor are owner-occupiers being forced out in disproportionate numbers. Instead, it reflects homeowners recognising that rapid capital growth is unlikely to return over the next year, prompting some to sell, reduce their debt exposure, downsize, or recycle their equity while buying their next home in the same discounted market. Do you have any final thoughts on the Pain and Gain Report before we turn to the macroeconomic data?

Kelvin Davidson (10:22):
You covered it well. I will just echo the point raised by Matt Ball from the New Zealand Property Investors' Federation on the Ryan Bridge radio show regarding inflation. For an investor cashing out of the property market entirely, a nominal loss or flat resale price is compounded by inflation because they walk away with less real purchasing power. For an owner-occupier, however, the dynamic is different: even if you sell your existing home for less than you paid, you are usually buying your next home in the exact same soft market, where prices have also fallen.

Nick Goodall (11:06):
Spot on, mate. Let us move on to last week's macroeconomic releases, which once again delivered mixed signals. We had the Stats NZ electronic card spending figures—which differed slightly from some of the commercial banks' internal card trackers—alongside the BusinessNZ Performance of Manufacturing Index (PMI) and the latest Stats NZ net migration data. Can you walk us through the key takeaways from those releases?

Kelvin Davidson (11:44):
The New Zealand economy remains very hard to read right now because positive and negative indicators keep contradicting each other. That is the exact conundrum facing the Reserve Bank of New Zealand as they assess underlying inflation pressures and whether households can handle higher interest rates.

First, Stats NZ electronic card retail spending fell again in October, marking the second or third consecutive monthly decline. Because electronic card figures are nominal and not adjusted for inflation—especially higher petrol and fuel prices—a drop in nominal spending means real retail sales volumes fell even further. Interestingly, economists at ANZ and Westpac noted that their internal credit and debit card spending trackers were not quite as weak as the official Stats NZ release, which might reflect market-share shifts between banks. Even so, it is clear household budgets remain under pressure.

Second, in complete contrast to weak retail spending, the BusinessNZ Performance of Manufacturing Index (PMI) recorded its sixteenth consecutive monthly rise, holding above the fifty-point expansion mark. Much of that manufacturing resilience is tied to New Zealand's strong primary sector—processing dairy and meat products for export—alongside broader export manufacturing.

Third, Stats NZ net migration figures showed another gentle rise. In the year to September 2026, annual net migration reached approximately twenty-two thousand six hundred—the highest annual total since December 2024. While departures of New Zealand citizens remain high, they have stopped accelerating, whereas new non-citizen arrivals have crept upward. At twenty-two thousand six hundred, net migration is trending higher and adding slowly to the labour force and consumer demand, though it remains below long-term historical averages and is not yet putting upward pressure on residential rents.

Nick Goodall (16:10):
"Patchy" is definitely the word for the economy right now. On that migration point, during a live Radio New Zealand (RNZ) interview last week, I was asked why property investors are still doing it tough when net migration is rising. As we have discussed on the podcast before, the missing link is household formation.

Because cost-of-living pressures remain acute, people are staying at home with their parents longer or living in larger flatting households rather than forming new independent households. While twenty-two thousand six hundred net migrants add some baseline housing demand, higher household occupancy combined with high rental listing stock means tenants have plenty of choice and bargaining power. If a landlord wants to secure a tenant today, they often have to trim their asking rent.

When people ask what the incoming government—once the four hundred thousand special votes are counted and coalition agreements are finalised—can do to turn the housing market around, I think the biggest lever is tackling household living costs. If cost-of-living pressures ease, household formation will recover, boosting both rental demand for investors and owner-occupier activity. Of course, many cost drivers—such as international trade tariffs, the conflict in Iran, and global oil prices—sit outside the New Zealand government's direct control, meaning any relief will be a medium-to-long-term story.

Before we wrap up our property discussion, there were two other industry stories last week worth highlighting. First, our Cotality analytics team provided custom listings data to Stuff examining withdrawn and unsold property listings. Across New Zealand, twenty-six percent of properties listed for sale over the past twelve months failed to sell within three months of going live. Interestingly, while Tāmaki Makaurau (Auckland) ranked high for stale and withdrawn listings, Te Whanganui-a-Tara (Wellington) did not even feature in the top ten regions. My interpretation is that Te Whanganui-a-Tara (Wellington) homeowners are already hyper-aware of their local market downturn, so unless they are realistic on price and genuinely need to sell, they simply do not list in the first place.

Second, Westpac New Zealand announced last week that it will begin adjusting mortgage lending criteria, deposit requirements, and loan terms for properties exposed to flooding and natural hazards. Kelvin, you answered several media queries on Westpac's announcement and have an article releasing this week analysing Cotality's flood vulnerability scores across the country. What is your take on Westpac's move?

Kelvin Davidson (21:48):
Factoring flood and landslide hazards into mortgage lending makes complete sense. Climate change is happening, and individual properties carry very different physical risks. Above all, moves like Westpac's raise public awareness so that prospective buyers go into transactions with their eyes wide open regarding insurance availability, future premiums, and resale risk.

When journalists asked me what Westpac's policy will do to New Zealand house prices, I pointed out that Westpac itself estimates only two to three percent of loan applications will be affected. Furthermore, Westpac is not cutting off finance altogether; rather, they are assessing risk and may require a higher deposit or shorter loan term on flood-prone homes. While we do not know exactly what other commercial banks are already doing behind the scenes, climate risk will gradually influence pricing over time rather than causing an overnight five percent drop in property values.

This week, we are publishing a Cotality research article aggregating our individual property flood risk scores up to the Territorial Authority level. Some smaller districts have a high percentage of flood-exposed homes, which is a major localised challenge for those communities. Meanwhile, our largest metropolitan centres have a lower percentage share of flood-prone homes, but because of their sheer population size, they represent a massive number of properties and significant dollar exposure for New Zealand's banking and insurance systems.

Nick Goodall (24:55):
I completely agree—getting consistent, transparent hazard data into everyone's hands is essential. Alongside private models like Cotality's property-level flood scores and Westpac's hazard data, the New Zealand government is launching a standardised National Flood Map next year. We have also contributed Cotality property data to the Strand Marsden research project led by the University of Otago, which models how flood events affect property demand and values over time.

It is tough for existing homeowners who bought twenty or thirty years ago without knowing their property sat in a localized drainage basin or on soil with poor water absorption, as reduced buyer demand and tighter lending criteria will likely weigh on their long-term capital growth. For future buyers, however, asking questions of real estate agents, mortgage brokers, insurers, and local councils is vital. Keep an eye out for Kelvin's flood vulnerability article on our website this week!

Have you got anything else on the work front before we commiserate over a tough sporting weekend, Kelvin?

Kelvin Davidson (28:37):
Just plenty of client events and travel over the next couple of weeks as we hit the peak end-of-year period, which is always great.

Nick Goodall (28:44):
Too right. If you are only here for the property and economic analysis, thank you very much for listening, and we will catch you next week!

Turning to the weekend's sport, Kelvin, it was a bruising Sunday: a frustrating loss for the All Blacks against Wales in Cardiff yesterday morning, followed by a heavy defeat for the Kiwis against the Australian Kangaroos in the rugby league final last night, and the Black Caps letting their one-day international slip against India after winning on Friday. At least football kept the positivity going, with the All Whites securing two wins and the Wellington Phoenix women's team claiming a three-one victory yesterday! How was your Canterbury Show Day long weekend in Ōtautahi (Christchurch)?

Kelvin Davidson (29:32):
We enjoyed the three-day Show Day long weekend here in Ōtautahi (Christchurch) and got plenty of work done around the section. On the sporting front, I was most disappointed by the Kiwis' rugby league loss, as the teams looked very even on paper against Australia.

As for the All Blacks losing to Wales after seventy-three years, I actually found it hard to be too upset! When I lived in the United Kingdom, I used to attend the Cardiff tests with a close Welsh friend, and the All Blacks won every single time. As soon as I saw the final score yesterday morning, I messaged him—and he and his family were in tears of joy. Rugby means so much to the Welsh people, and with sixty-five thousand fans singing under the closed roof in Cardiff, the atmosphere would have been incredible. As long as the All Blacks beat England at Twickenham next week, I can live with Wales having their moment!

Nick Goodall (30:55):
That is a great perspective—New Zealanders definitely have a soft spot and strong affinity for Wales. Having woken up at three o'clock in the morning to watch it live, though, I found it pretty frustrating! Full credit to the Welsh defence, which was heroic, but the All Blacks' first-half discipline, tackling, and one-dimensional attack late in the game will face some harsh internal reviews. Seeing Richie Mo'unga still readjusting to test rugby after his time in Japan and injury layoff, alongside questions around halfback Noah Hotham and whether Damian McKenzie could have sparked the attack, leaves plenty for the coaching staff to ponder. That said, the pre-match haka and the Cardiff crowd's response under the stadium lights were truly special.

As for the Kiwis last night, I actually missed the kickoff because my wife and I went to the Flight of the Conchords concert here in Te Whanganui-a-Tara (Wellington), which was an absolute highlight! Bret McKenzie and Jemaine Clement were hilarious, mixing fresh variations into their classic songs alongside some great guest appearances. When I checked my phone afterwards and saw the Kiwis had conceded early tries against Australia, I watched for a bit at home before turning it off early—I simply cannot stomach losing to Australia!

Outside of that, we stained our home fence a sharp dark black, coached my son's Saturday morning cricket team for the second week running, and now I am looking forward to heading along to the Basin Reserve here in Te Whanganui-a-Tara (Wellington) this Friday and Saturday for the Black Caps Test match against India. I will also see you this Thursday night for our Cotality client end-of-year dinner! Any final thoughts before we sign off, mate?

Kelvin Davidson (35:52):
That is everything from me—just two or three hectic weeks of events ahead before we start winding down for the Christmas break.

Nick Goodall (36:03):
Looking forward to seeing you on Thursday night, mate, and hopefully spotting a few of our loyal listeners on the Basin Reserve embankment this Friday and Saturday! Thank you, as per usual, for your insights, Kelvin, and thank you to everyone for tuning in. Please get in touch with any questions or feedback. My name is Nick, he is Kelvin, and you have been listening to the New Zealand Property Market Podcast. Mā te wā.

Related Resources

 (
)
No items found.